4.2
Benefits of Well-Managed Trail Networks
4.2
Benefits of Well-Managed Trail Networks
4.2
Benefits of Well-Managed Trail Networks

A well-planned trail system connects riders with the communities. Image Credit: Bike Corris Ltd.
A well-managed trail network that meets the three pillars of sustainability (environmental, social, economic) is more likely to be appreciated by users, resulting in more visiting riders, and a greater number of return visits.
Environmental sustainability can be achieved by working within established land management plans to take account of habitats and conservation areas, and to avoid areas earmarked for planned forest operations. Good management of how people enter and use a site is also critical to avoid users causing damage, for example by shortcutting through protected areas.
Good social sustainability considers how the trail is designed and maintained. If a voluntary model is used, there must be enough volunteers to keep up with the workload the design and rider numbers dictate. In addition, if the venue is likely to attract visitors, proper parking provision must be planned to avoid creating tensions with local community.
Economic sustainability plans how the trail will be paid for, both in construction cost and operational revenue. Careful integration with local community facilities such as housing, cafés and parks can build can help build an income stream from both local users of and benefactors from the trail.
Except for trail centres and private bike parks, the UK trail network has mostly evolved without dedicated planning and design. This is particularly true of wild trails constructed in the Covid19 lockdown era, when restrictions forced amateur trail developers to create lines on hillsides and woodland that would not have been found suitable for development had the full process taken place. The fact people have taken trail building into their own hands demonstrates the demand and social value of networks to a community.
Across the UK volunteers have engaged with land managers to try and protect these networks by achieving some type of agreement. The efforts the volunteers and land managers who have pioneered this work must be recognised and applauded. However, positive results have been reported to take many years to achieve, and many more volunteers reported that initial successful progress had become thwarted by the lack of approved process and resource in the land management body.
One-to-one interviews revealed volunteers who have not received any agreement for their trails feel there is currently a high risk of dwindling enthusiasm for formal engagement. This project is making land management partners aware of this risk and providing assistance to create the processes needed to allow land managers and trail associations to harness enthusiasm and direct volunteers’ efforts to positive solutions.
Professional Trail Developer interview, Summer 2024
“Trail networks can bring significant economic benefits to local communities. Promoting these benefits helps build support for the trails.”
The Three Pillars of Sustainability
In the ideal world, a well-planned trail system should be designed and built around the three pillars of sustainability:
Environmental sustainability involves managing resources and ensuring the trail system sits in harmony with its host environment.
Social sustainability focuses on the balance of wellbeing and benefit to the intended user group while not creating a negative impact on other users. It also includes integration with community facilities.
Economic sustainability requires the system to have a funding pathway to ensure it remains fit for purpose and does not deteriorate over time, becoming dangerous to users or hazardous to the environment. It must include correct assessment of the maintenance required against the resource (funding and volunteers) available.
By understanding why the trails are needed, who will use them and what kind of experience is to be provided, the designer and land manager can collaborate to determine how the network fits alongside their operational and statutory obligations.
What Good Looks Like
Trail builders and land mangers interviewed cited several themes as essential in the ideal trail network. For the best chance of success and sustainability, both parties agreed the network should:
Be designed and constructed in harmony with the landscape and environment.
Offer a range of trail-grade choices with opportunities to progress a rider’s skills.
Integrate and engage with the local community.
Meet the needs of local riders and/or the intended visitor group.
Have good supporting infrastructure and connectivity.
Have a planned resilient maintenance model.
Be able to evolve to meet future needs.
Although it is easiest to start designing a new trail network, existing networks can be assessed and improved using this approach retrospectively.
Controlling Liability
It is essential that land managers control their exposure to liability from those using their land. By using good planning and applying best safety practice, risks can be mitigated without spoiling users’ enjoyment or the natural feel of the environment.
For example:
Risk of riders colliding with walkers at footpath crossings can be reduced by designing in speed control features and improving visibility.
Land Manager, Summer 2024
“The more similar trail associations are to our systems, the happier we are.”
Landscape Limitations
While we recognise the need for greater trail provision across the UK, we must be realistic in what can be achieved where. While it is possible to provide entry to mid-grade trails in many landscapes, top end trail provision across UK is mostly dictated by the topography of the area. For instance, mountainous regions such as North Wales and Scotland are renowned for their long and technical trails, whereas regions with less total elevation can still provide short and steep downhill tracks, or dirt jumps, to challenge the more highly skilled rider. As technical preferences vary by region, it is essential to listen to the opinions of skilled riders to ensure provision meets the needs of the geography and community of each area.
Trail associations and land managers rightly pointed out that not all sites are topographically suitable for all users (and trail types), and there are safety benefits to separating more technically challenging trails from more family orientated areas.
Addressing the Grade Imbalance
Analysis of Trailforks data and informal discussions at workshops across the UK revealed intriguing examples of grade imbalance across the country.
For example:
Sites with good beginner and intermediate trails were found lacking in options for riders to progress their skills any further.
Other areas renowned for mountain biking had a wide variety of trails at the hardest grades making for a great visitor destination, but no easier provision to enable local newcomers to the sport.
Whilst it is not possible to build trails of every grade at every location, it would be advantageous for more areas around the UK to offer the variety and progress that riders value.
A well-managed trail network that meets the three pillars of sustainability (environmental, social, economic) is more likely to be appreciated by users, resulting in more visiting riders, and a greater number of return visits.
Environmental sustainability can be achieved by working within established land management plans to take account of habitats and conservation areas, and to avoid areas earmarked for planned forest operations. Good management of how people enter and use a site is also critical to avoid users causing damage, for example by shortcutting through protected areas.
Good social sustainability considers how the trail is designed and maintained. If a voluntary model is used, there must be enough volunteers to keep up with the workload the design and rider numbers dictate. In addition, if the venue is likely to attract visitors, proper parking provision must be planned to avoid creating tensions with local community.
Economic sustainability plans how the trail will be paid for, both in construction cost and operational revenue. Careful integration with local community facilities such as housing, cafés and parks can build can help build an income stream from both local users of and benefactors from the trail.
Except for trail centres and private bike parks, the UK trail network has mostly evolved without dedicated planning and design. This is particularly true of wild trails constructed in the Covid19 lockdown era, when restrictions forced amateur trail developers to create lines on hillsides and woodland that would not have been found suitable for development had the full process taken place. The fact people have taken trail building into their own hands demonstrates the demand and social value of networks to a community.
Across the UK volunteers have engaged with land managers to try and protect these networks by achieving some type of agreement. The efforts the volunteers and land managers who have pioneered this work must be recognised and applauded. However, positive results have been reported to take many years to achieve, and many more volunteers reported that initial successful progress had become thwarted by the lack of approved process and resource in the land management body.
One-to-one interviews revealed volunteers who have not received any agreement for their trails feel there is currently a high risk of dwindling enthusiasm for formal engagement. This project is making land management partners aware of this risk and providing assistance to create the processes needed to allow land managers and trail associations to harness enthusiasm and direct volunteers’ efforts to positive solutions.
Professional Trail Developer interview, Summer 2024
“Trail networks can bring significant economic benefits to local communities. Promoting these benefits helps build support for the trails.”
The Three Pillars of Sustainability
In the ideal world, a well-planned trail system should be designed and built around the three pillars of sustainability:
Environmental sustainability involves managing resources and ensuring the trail system sits in harmony with its host environment.
Social sustainability focuses on the balance of wellbeing and benefit to the intended user group while not creating a negative impact on other users. It also includes integration with community facilities.
Economic sustainability requires the system to have a funding pathway to ensure it remains fit for purpose and does not deteriorate over time, becoming dangerous to users or hazardous to the environment. It must include correct assessment of the maintenance required against the resource (funding and volunteers) available.
By understanding why the trails are needed, who will use them and what kind of experience is to be provided, the designer and land manager can collaborate to determine how the network fits alongside their operational and statutory obligations.
What Good Looks Like
Trail builders and land mangers interviewed cited several themes as essential in the ideal trail network. For the best chance of success and sustainability, both parties agreed the network should:
Be designed and constructed in harmony with the landscape and environment.
Offer a range of trail-grade choices with opportunities to progress a rider’s skills.
Integrate and engage with the local community.
Meet the needs of local riders and/or the intended visitor group.
Have good supporting infrastructure and connectivity.
Have a planned resilient maintenance model.
Be able to evolve to meet future needs.
Although it is easiest to start designing a new trail network, existing networks can be assessed and improved using this approach retrospectively.
Controlling Liability
It is essential that land managers control their exposure to liability from those using their land. By using good planning and applying best safety practice, risks can be mitigated without spoiling users’ enjoyment or the natural feel of the environment.
For example:
Risk of riders colliding with walkers at footpath crossings can be reduced by designing in speed control features and improving visibility.
Land Manager, Summer 2024
“The more similar trail associations are to our systems, the happier we are.”
Landscape Limitations
While we recognise the need for greater trail provision across the UK, we must be realistic in what can be achieved where. While it is possible to provide entry to mid-grade trails in many landscapes, top end trail provision across UK is mostly dictated by the topography of the area. For instance, mountainous regions such as North Wales and Scotland are renowned for their long and technical trails, whereas regions with less total elevation can still provide short and steep downhill tracks, or dirt jumps, to challenge the more highly skilled rider. As technical preferences vary by region, it is essential to listen to the opinions of skilled riders to ensure provision meets the needs of the geography and community of each area.
Trail associations and land managers rightly pointed out that not all sites are topographically suitable for all users (and trail types), and there are safety benefits to separating more technically challenging trails from more family orientated areas.
Addressing the Grade Imbalance
Analysis of Trailforks data and informal discussions at workshops across the UK revealed intriguing examples of grade imbalance across the country.
For example:
Sites with good beginner and intermediate trails were found lacking in options for riders to progress their skills any further.
Other areas renowned for mountain biking had a wide variety of trails at the hardest grades making for a great visitor destination, but no easier provision to enable local newcomers to the sport.
Whilst it is not possible to build trails of every grade at every location, it would be advantageous for more areas around the UK to offer the variety and progress that riders value.
A well-managed trail network that meets the three pillars of sustainability (environmental, social, economic) is more likely to be appreciated by users, resulting in more visiting riders, and a greater number of return visits.
Environmental sustainability can be achieved by working within established land management plans to take account of habitats and conservation areas, and to avoid areas earmarked for planned forest operations. Good management of how people enter and use a site is also critical to avoid users causing damage, for example by shortcutting through protected areas.
Good social sustainability considers how the trail is designed and maintained. If a voluntary model is used, there must be enough volunteers to keep up with the workload the design and rider numbers dictate. In addition, if the venue is likely to attract visitors, proper parking provision must be planned to avoid creating tensions with local community.
Economic sustainability plans how the trail will be paid for, both in construction cost and operational revenue. Careful integration with local community facilities such as housing, cafés and parks can build can help build an income stream from both local users of and benefactors from the trail.
Except for trail centres and private bike parks, the UK trail network has mostly evolved without dedicated planning and design. This is particularly true of wild trails constructed in the Covid19 lockdown era, when restrictions forced amateur trail developers to create lines on hillsides and woodland that would not have been found suitable for development had the full process taken place. The fact people have taken trail building into their own hands demonstrates the demand and social value of networks to a community.
Across the UK volunteers have engaged with land managers to try and protect these networks by achieving some type of agreement. The efforts the volunteers and land managers who have pioneered this work must be recognised and applauded. However, positive results have been reported to take many years to achieve, and many more volunteers reported that initial successful progress had become thwarted by the lack of approved process and resource in the land management body.
One-to-one interviews revealed volunteers who have not received any agreement for their trails feel there is currently a high risk of dwindling enthusiasm for formal engagement. This project is making land management partners aware of this risk and providing assistance to create the processes needed to allow land managers and trail associations to harness enthusiasm and direct volunteers’ efforts to positive solutions.
Professional Trail Developer interview, Summer 2024
“Trail networks can bring significant economic benefits to local communities. Promoting these benefits helps build support for the trails.”
The Three Pillars of Sustainability
In the ideal world, a well-planned trail system should be designed and built around the three pillars of sustainability:
Environmental sustainability involves managing resources and ensuring the trail system sits in harmony with its host environment.
Social sustainability focuses on the balance of wellbeing and benefit to the intended user group while not creating a negative impact on other users. It also includes integration with community facilities.
Economic sustainability requires the system to have a funding pathway to ensure it remains fit for purpose and does not deteriorate over time, becoming dangerous to users or hazardous to the environment. It must include correct assessment of the maintenance required against the resource (funding and volunteers) available.
By understanding why the trails are needed, who will use them and what kind of experience is to be provided, the designer and land manager can collaborate to determine how the network fits alongside their operational and statutory obligations.
What Good Looks Like
Trail builders and land mangers interviewed cited several themes as essential in the ideal trail network. For the best chance of success and sustainability, both parties agreed the network should:
Be designed and constructed in harmony with the landscape and environment.
Offer a range of trail-grade choices with opportunities to progress a rider’s skills.
Integrate and engage with the local community.
Meet the needs of local riders and/or the intended visitor group.
Have good supporting infrastructure and connectivity.
Have a planned resilient maintenance model.
Be able to evolve to meet future needs.
Although it is easiest to start designing a new trail network, existing networks can be assessed and improved using this approach retrospectively.
Controlling Liability
It is essential that land managers control their exposure to liability from those using their land. By using good planning and applying best safety practice, risks can be mitigated without spoiling users’ enjoyment or the natural feel of the environment.
For example:
Risk of riders colliding with walkers at footpath crossings can be reduced by designing in speed control features and improving visibility.
Land Manager, Summer 2024
“The more similar trail associations are to our systems, the happier we are.”
Landscape Limitations
While we recognise the need for greater trail provision across the UK, we must be realistic in what can be achieved where. While it is possible to provide entry to mid-grade trails in many landscapes, top end trail provision across UK is mostly dictated by the topography of the area. For instance, mountainous regions such as North Wales and Scotland are renowned for their long and technical trails, whereas regions with less total elevation can still provide short and steep downhill tracks, or dirt jumps, to challenge the more highly skilled rider. As technical preferences vary by region, it is essential to listen to the opinions of skilled riders to ensure provision meets the needs of the geography and community of each area.
Trail associations and land managers rightly pointed out that not all sites are topographically suitable for all users (and trail types), and there are safety benefits to separating more technically challenging trails from more family orientated areas.
Addressing the Grade Imbalance
Analysis of Trailforks data and informal discussions at workshops across the UK revealed intriguing examples of grade imbalance across the country.
For example:
Sites with good beginner and intermediate trails were found lacking in options for riders to progress their skills any further.
Other areas renowned for mountain biking had a wide variety of trails at the hardest grades making for a great visitor destination, but no easier provision to enable local newcomers to the sport.
Whilst it is not possible to build trails of every grade at every location, it would be advantageous for more areas around the UK to offer the variety and progress that riders value.
Sponsors and Steering Group