2.6
How Trails Are Managed
2.6
How Trails Are Managed
2.6
How Trails Are Managed
Visiting sites across the UK revealed a wide range of trail management models being used to good effect (Ref 2.6.A). As the workshops and interviews continued, it became increasingly clear that there is no “one size fits all” solution. Instead we found a range of tools being applied, with the appropriate level of management varying from site to site. It quickly became clear that all management models were built on trust and clear communication between the mountain bike community and land management team responsible. All parties were keen to express that this trust took time to build and must be cultivated and maintained.
Managers showed a strong desire to move away from ignoring or tolerating mountain biking and, to provide the most robust defence in court in the event of a claim, use management methods as similar as possible to their own (Ref 2.6.B). Of the 34 Trail Associations to respond, 67% reported successful dealings with their land manager with 44% having secured adoption of their trails through agreement or permission with the land manager.
However, there are several examples of other management models such as partnership working and “trail stewardship”. A further 14% of responding associations had reached a less formal position with permission or stewardship agreements in place.
Looking into the Other responses we found a mixture of established Trail Associations awaiting progress with the land managers and informal groups unsure how to make progress.
This project will examine all management options with the critical elements being to understand the scope and limitation of each model, and how the characteristics of any site determine which one suits it best. Each site will have individual rider characteristics such as user numbers, proportions of locals or visitors, and media exposure. The site manager’s constraints surrounding conservation and operational factors, and personal risk tolerance will also be a significant driver to the model required.
Land Manager one-to-one interview, Summer 2024
“Engaging the local community in trail development and maintenance builds support and ensures the sustainability of the trails.”
The Effect of Media Exposure
When considering management models, we must remember all sites are live entities which can change in character and use, meaning the most appropriate model can change. E.g. If a race is held and the site becomes massively more popular, increased management and maintenance may be required; if tree disease become an issue, the site may need additional mitigation measures or alteration. The mountain bike community, especially social media creators, need to understand the impact they are creating on user numbers and attitudes by exposing trails to a global audience.
Rural Police Officer one-to-one interview, Summer 2024
“After media exposure we suddenly have people travelling from quite far afield to try out these trails. The issue is there is not the infrastructure for people to drive and park up. That's where we start to see conflict.”
Visiting sites across the UK revealed a wide range of trail management models being used to good effect (Ref 2.6.A). As the workshops and interviews continued, it became increasingly clear that there is no “one size fits all” solution. Instead we found a range of tools being applied, with the appropriate level of management varying from site to site. It quickly became clear that all management models were built on trust and clear communication between the mountain bike community and land management team responsible. All parties were keen to express that this trust took time to build and must be cultivated and maintained.
Managers showed a strong desire to move away from ignoring or tolerating mountain biking and, to provide the most robust defence in court in the event of a claim, use management methods as similar as possible to their own (Ref 2.6.B). Of the 34 Trail Associations to respond, 67% reported successful dealings with their land manager with 44% having secured adoption of their trails through agreement or permission with the land manager.
However, there are several examples of other management models such as partnership working and “trail stewardship”. A further 14% of responding associations had reached a less formal position with permission or stewardship agreements in place.
Looking into the Other responses we found a mixture of established Trail Associations awaiting progress with the land managers and informal groups unsure how to make progress.
This project will examine all management options with the critical elements being to understand the scope and limitation of each model, and how the characteristics of any site determine which one suits it best. Each site will have individual rider characteristics such as user numbers, proportions of locals or visitors, and media exposure. The site manager’s constraints surrounding conservation and operational factors, and personal risk tolerance will also be a significant driver to the model required.
Land Manager one-to-one interview, Summer 2024
“Engaging the local community in trail development and maintenance builds support and ensures the sustainability of the trails.”
The Effect of Media Exposure
When considering management models, we must remember all sites are live entities which can change in character and use, meaning the most appropriate model can change. E.g. If a race is held and the site becomes massively more popular, increased management and maintenance may be required; if tree disease become an issue, the site may need additional mitigation measures or alteration. The mountain bike community, especially social media creators, need to understand the impact they are creating on user numbers and attitudes by exposing trails to a global audience.
Rural Police Officer one-to-one interview, Summer 2024
“After media exposure we suddenly have people travelling from quite far afield to try out these trails. The issue is there is not the infrastructure for people to drive and park up. That's where we start to see conflict.”
Visiting sites across the UK revealed a wide range of trail management models being used to good effect (Ref 2.6.A). As the workshops and interviews continued, it became increasingly clear that there is no “one size fits all” solution. Instead we found a range of tools being applied, with the appropriate level of management varying from site to site. It quickly became clear that all management models were built on trust and clear communication between the mountain bike community and land management team responsible. All parties were keen to express that this trust took time to build and must be cultivated and maintained.
Managers showed a strong desire to move away from ignoring or tolerating mountain biking and, to provide the most robust defence in court in the event of a claim, use management methods as similar as possible to their own (Ref 2.6.B). Of the 34 Trail Associations to respond, 67% reported successful dealings with their land manager with 44% having secured adoption of their trails through agreement or permission with the land manager.
However, there are several examples of other management models such as partnership working and “trail stewardship”. A further 14% of responding associations had reached a less formal position with permission or stewardship agreements in place.
Looking into the Other responses we found a mixture of established Trail Associations awaiting progress with the land managers and informal groups unsure how to make progress.
This project will examine all management options with the critical elements being to understand the scope and limitation of each model, and how the characteristics of any site determine which one suits it best. Each site will have individual rider characteristics such as user numbers, proportions of locals or visitors, and media exposure. The site manager’s constraints surrounding conservation and operational factors, and personal risk tolerance will also be a significant driver to the model required.
Land Manager one-to-one interview, Summer 2024
“Engaging the local community in trail development and maintenance builds support and ensures the sustainability of the trails.”
The Effect of Media Exposure
When considering management models, we must remember all sites are live entities which can change in character and use, meaning the most appropriate model can change. E.g. If a race is held and the site becomes massively more popular, increased management and maintenance may be required; if tree disease become an issue, the site may need additional mitigation measures or alteration. The mountain bike community, especially social media creators, need to understand the impact they are creating on user numbers and attitudes by exposing trails to a global audience.
Rural Police Officer one-to-one interview, Summer 2024
“After media exposure we suddenly have people travelling from quite far afield to try out these trails. The issue is there is not the infrastructure for people to drive and park up. That's where we start to see conflict.”
2.6.A
The Management Model Hierarchy
2.6.B
Current and Desired Management Strategies
2.6.C
Rider Figures Showing Media Exposure Impact at Cwm Rhaeadr Trail
Sponsors and Steering Group