1.2.2
Moral and Legal Obligations
1.2.2
Moral and Legal Obligations
1.2.2
Moral and Legal Obligations

Land managers have a wide range of responsibilities, often over large geographic areas.
All landowners find themselves at the centre of multiple and sometimes complex and potentially conflicting legal responsibilities whilst going about their daily business. Where example laws are given for England and Wales, corresponding legislation is applicable in Northern Ireland and Scotland. This is omitted only for readability.
Under UK law (Occupiers' Liability Acts of 1957 and 1984), landowners must take reasonable steps to protect both invited visitors and trespassers from harm whilst on their property.
The Health and Safety at Work Act (HSW Act 2015) holds the landowner responsible for safety of the public, as well as their workforce, during management operations.
The landowner is also legally responsible for environmental obligations under the Environmental Protection Act 1990 and the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981.
Finally, although it may seem easiest to meet the above laws by excluding the public from the land, landowners must provide access according to the laws of their home country and are under increasing pressure for greater public access.
The Need for a Robust Defence in Court
Lack of understanding of legal precedent in mountain bike case law causes significant anxiety within the Land Management communities. As a claim in this area is most likely to be under civil law, the proportion of blame, and compensation owed, would be determined by a judge. A private business can take out insurance to cover these claims, where as public bodies are “self-insured” with no upper limit on the amount of compensation a court can award in the event of a claim, they reasonably fear the impact of successful claims which could amount to a significant proportion of a public bodies’ annual budget. More serious than civil claims, failure to meet environmental and safety laws can potentially expose the organisation to criminal prosecution and individuals to criminal records and custodial sentences.
Balancing Risk and Benefit
Land managers engaging with this project appreciate the benefits visitors get from using their sites, and do not wish to “sanitise” the countryside. In fact, the opposite is true, with all land managers on the steering group following the Visitor Safety Group (VSG) principles of balancing risk and benefit to visitors and keeping as natural an appearance to their estates as practicable.
To make up their legal defence, land managers have a range of tools to prove their MTB trails are fit for purpose. These include:
Design and build specifications.
Inspection and maintenance schedules.
User information provision.
Risk Assessments and Method Statements (RAMS) for all work being carried out.
Since mountain bikers have expanded the trail network by constructing their own trails, land mangers require similarly robust processes to provide a comparable level of defence in court. At present only a small proportion of volunteer trail groups have been successful in signing a management agreement, often as a result of long and hard work from both parties, with timescales typically in months and years. If formal adoption of trails is required, standardised processes and templates are needed to ease the workload for all involved and produce fair and consistent results. Other longer-term options could include changing legislation to reduce landowner liability, reducing duty of care in relation to risk, and therefore exposure to claims.
All landowners find themselves at the centre of multiple and sometimes complex and potentially conflicting legal responsibilities whilst going about their daily business. Where example laws are given for England and Wales, corresponding legislation is applicable in Northern Ireland and Scotland. This is omitted only for readability.
Under UK law (Occupiers' Liability Acts of 1957 and 1984), landowners must take reasonable steps to protect both invited visitors and trespassers from harm whilst on their property.
The Health and Safety at Work Act (HSW Act 2015) holds the landowner responsible for safety of the public, as well as their workforce, during management operations.
The landowner is also legally responsible for environmental obligations under the Environmental Protection Act 1990 and the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981.
Finally, although it may seem easiest to meet the above laws by excluding the public from the land, landowners must provide access according to the laws of their home country and are under increasing pressure for greater public access.
The Need for a Robust Defence in Court
Lack of understanding of legal precedent in mountain bike case law causes significant anxiety within the Land Management communities. As a claim in this area is most likely to be under civil law, the proportion of blame, and compensation owed, would be determined by a judge. A private business can take out insurance to cover these claims, where as public bodies are “self-insured” with no upper limit on the amount of compensation a court can award in the event of a claim, they reasonably fear the impact of successful claims which could amount to a significant proportion of a public bodies’ annual budget. More serious than civil claims, failure to meet environmental and safety laws can potentially expose the organisation to criminal prosecution and individuals to criminal records and custodial sentences.
Balancing Risk and Benefit
Land managers engaging with this project appreciate the benefits visitors get from using their sites, and do not wish to “sanitise” the countryside. In fact, the opposite is true, with all land managers on the steering group following the Visitor Safety Group (VSG) principles of balancing risk and benefit to visitors and keeping as natural an appearance to their estates as practicable.
To make up their legal defence, land managers have a range of tools to prove their MTB trails are fit for purpose. These include:
Design and build specifications.
Inspection and maintenance schedules.
User information provision.
Risk Assessments and Method Statements (RAMS) for all work being carried out.
Since mountain bikers have expanded the trail network by constructing their own trails, land mangers require similarly robust processes to provide a comparable level of defence in court. At present only a small proportion of volunteer trail groups have been successful in signing a management agreement, often as a result of long and hard work from both parties, with timescales typically in months and years. If formal adoption of trails is required, standardised processes and templates are needed to ease the workload for all involved and produce fair and consistent results. Other longer-term options could include changing legislation to reduce landowner liability, reducing duty of care in relation to risk, and therefore exposure to claims.
All landowners find themselves at the centre of multiple and sometimes complex and potentially conflicting legal responsibilities whilst going about their daily business. Where example laws are given for England and Wales, corresponding legislation is applicable in Northern Ireland and Scotland. This is omitted only for readability.
Under UK law (Occupiers' Liability Acts of 1957 and 1984), landowners must take reasonable steps to protect both invited visitors and trespassers from harm whilst on their property.
The Health and Safety at Work Act (HSW Act 2015) holds the landowner responsible for safety of the public, as well as their workforce, during management operations.
The landowner is also legally responsible for environmental obligations under the Environmental Protection Act 1990 and the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981.
Finally, although it may seem easiest to meet the above laws by excluding the public from the land, landowners must provide access according to the laws of their home country and are under increasing pressure for greater public access.
The Need for a Robust Defence in Court
Lack of understanding of legal precedent in mountain bike case law causes significant anxiety within the Land Management communities. As a claim in this area is most likely to be under civil law, the proportion of blame, and compensation owed, would be determined by a judge. A private business can take out insurance to cover these claims, where as public bodies are “self-insured” with no upper limit on the amount of compensation a court can award in the event of a claim, they reasonably fear the impact of successful claims which could amount to a significant proportion of a public bodies’ annual budget. More serious than civil claims, failure to meet environmental and safety laws can potentially expose the organisation to criminal prosecution and individuals to criminal records and custodial sentences.
Balancing Risk and Benefit
Land managers engaging with this project appreciate the benefits visitors get from using their sites, and do not wish to “sanitise” the countryside. In fact, the opposite is true, with all land managers on the steering group following the Visitor Safety Group (VSG) principles of balancing risk and benefit to visitors and keeping as natural an appearance to their estates as practicable.
To make up their legal defence, land managers have a range of tools to prove their MTB trails are fit for purpose. These include:
Design and build specifications.
Inspection and maintenance schedules.
User information provision.
Risk Assessments and Method Statements (RAMS) for all work being carried out.
Since mountain bikers have expanded the trail network by constructing their own trails, land mangers require similarly robust processes to provide a comparable level of defence in court. At present only a small proportion of volunteer trail groups have been successful in signing a management agreement, often as a result of long and hard work from both parties, with timescales typically in months and years. If formal adoption of trails is required, standardised processes and templates are needed to ease the workload for all involved and produce fair and consistent results. Other longer-term options could include changing legislation to reduce landowner liability, reducing duty of care in relation to risk, and therefore exposure to claims.
Sponsors and Steering Group