3.2

Organisations in the Governance Space

3.2

Organisations in the Governance Space

3.2

Organisations in the Governance Space

Formal trail development can produce durable and beautiful places to ride.

Group 1

Sporting Governance

Cycling Ireland (& Cycling Ulster)

Established: Current form 2007. Historic line traceable to 1878.

Advantages: 

  • Club model facilitates racing and kids’ clubs.

  • Has achieved Stewardship trail management agreement via club at Rostrevor trail centre.

  • Small government so easier access to politicians.

  • Ability to strike local agreements with councils.

Disadvantages:

  • Limited overall budget and paid staff, relies heavily on volunteers to deliver programmes.

  • Governance can only reflect what its members inform it. Does membership reflect all riders adequately?

  • Traditionally focused on road/track and only recently broadening to focus on other disciplines.

  • No current remit for operating rider constructed trails. 

  • Has had difficulties in engagement with forestry management on both sides of the border in terms of access for recreation and racing.

  • Currently does not appear to represent small independent groups in engagement with land managers.

  • Lack of devolved government has slowed/ stopped progress until very recently.

Beicio Cymru (formerly Welsh Cycling)

Established: 2002

Advantages: 

  • Recent relaunch with greater grassroots focus including “Festiva” family friendly events.

  • Work with Sport Wales to help strategic investment into cycling infrastructure in all disciplines, including mountain biking.

  • Smaller size and devolved status may increase organisational flexibility. 

Disadvantages:

  • Had MTB Development Officers developing clubs and talent pathways as recently as 2019, but no longer has human resource available for this.

  • Historically not a large player in the mountain bike space, but becoming more involved via the Festiva (bike festival) programme.

  • Governance can only reflect what its members inform it. Does membership reflect all riders adequately?

British Cycling

Established: 1988

Advantages: 

  • Size and establishment.

  • “The Governing Body” seen as expert point of contact by land managers and third-party stakeholders.

  • Established entry level and elite rider programmes.

  • Provider of coaching and leader training, and insurance at all levels.

  • Works with Sport England to help strategic investment into cycling infrastructure in all disciplines, including mountain biking, via the Places to Ride scheme.

Disadvantages:

  • Size and history can create organisational inertia.

  • Perceived road and track bias by MTB community.

  • Governance can only reflect what its members inform it. Perceived lack of representation of the “typical rider”.

Scottish Cycling

Established: 1952

Advantages: 

  • History of supporting pioneering mountain bike initiatives including Scottish Mountain Bike Leaders Association and DMBinS.

  • Support for Scottish national race series' SXC and SDA.

  • Delivering Rock Up & Ride – an initiative to inspire children into cycling by providing fun MTB & BMX sessions and providing bikes to those who can’t afford them.

  • Supported many young athletes to go on to the British Cycling athlete development programmes. 

  • Work with Sport Scotland to help strategic investment into cycling infrastructure in all disciplines, including mountain biking.

Disadvantages:

  • Perceived as a road and track based organisation by some as it was founded by clubs from those disciplines.

  • Does not run its own individual membership product, rather counts British Cycling members that are based in Scotland as its membership base. This can lead to confusion of its role.

  • Clubs are the membership of Scottish Cycling and support to clubs is prioritised through its funding allocation from Sport Scotland.


Group 2

Recreational Governance

Cycling UK (formerly the Cyclists Touring Club CTC)

Established: 1878

Advantages: 

  • Long history of advocating successfully for cycle access to the countryside.

  • Creator of several long distance offroad journeys, the latest being the 2022 Traws Eryri in North Wales. 

  • Contributor to transport planning.

  • Provider of insurance.

  • Provider of basic cycle training.

Disadvantages:

  • More road and transport focused with no clear policy for mountain biking.

Developing Mountain Biking in Scotland (DMBinS)

Established: 2009

Advantages: 

  • Works to deliver a National Strategy.

  • Internationally respected.

  • Creates network of key stakeholders.

  • Negotiation and solution focussed.

  • Regional staff to deliver projects.

Disadvantages:

  • Model potentially restricted to certain size of country / area / population. 

  • Relies on annual grant funding for national and regional posts – this is time consuming and is fragile.

UK MTB Trail Alliance

Established: 2023

Advantages: 

  • Generates excitement in the MTB community about “something new”.

  • Grassroots base in touch with engaged enthusiast mountain bikers “on the ground”

  • Online platform and monthly Zoom meetings for networking and knowledge sharing.

  • Forming an umbrella organisation to bring together trail associations, informal trail groups and bike parks across the UK.

Disadvantages:

  • Voluntary structure risks resilience and capacity. 

  • Yet to develop formal membership structure to act on behalf of others, but currently in the process of registering as a charity.

  • Not recognised as “expert” by some land management stakeholders, who expressed preference for dealing with NGBs.

Walk Wheel Cyclet Tust (formerly Sustrans)

Established: 1977

Advantages: 

  • Strong record in cycling advocacy and policy influence. 

  • Provider of toolbox of cycling resources for design and planning professionals. 

  • Facilitator of the National Cycle Network.

  • Recognise the need for better connection of people to green and public space.

Disadvantages:

  • Primarily road and transport focused.

  • Do not focus on the progression from cycling for travel, to cycling for sporting pleasure.


Group 3

Other Governance

Bicycle Association

Established: 1973 (Traceable to 1890)

Advantages: 

  • Consumer focussed. 

  • Large reach into the cycle industry. 

  • Provider of training pathways for the industry 

  • Could leverage funding from industry. 

Disadvantages:

  • Focussed on supporting retail, not use of bicycles. 

  • Not mountain bike specific. 

  • No funding distribution pathways to support trails projects. 

IMBA Europe

Established: 2012

Advantages: 

  • International cooperation on advocacy and trail development.

  • Provision of training for volunteers.

  • Wide range of resources available.

Disadvantages:

  • Centralised European focus needs “translating” to each UK home nation.

Mountain Bike Wales

Established: 2004

Advantages: 

  • Set up as a Community Interest Company (CIC) to draw down funding, with Directors and a Steering Group overseeing investment.

  • Has previously acted as the voice of the mountain bike sector in Wales.

  • Direct links to the Welsh Government.

  • Website promoting Wales trail centres, bike parks approved trails.

Disadvantages:

  • Irregular funding limits investment in trails

  • Has lacked leadership and governance in recent years, limiting its reach and relevance for the sector.

  • No clear strategy for developing MTB.

Outdoor Industries Association (OIA)

Trade body for manufacturers, retailers and others providing products and services for the outdoor leisure pursuits market. Established: 2009

Advantages: 

  • Understanding of physical and mental health benefits.

  • Discusses industry issues at governmental level.

  • Feed into National Strategies ie. Sports Strategy.

Disadvantages:

  • Not clear how MTB would fit within in the structure at present (Who would join to represent MTB?).

Group 1

Sporting Governance

Cycling Ireland (& Cycling Ulster)

Established: Current form 2007. Historic line traceable to 1878.

Advantages: 

  • Club model facilitates racing and kids’ clubs.

  • Has achieved Stewardship trail management agreement via club at Rostrevor trail centre.

  • Small government so easier access to politicians.

  • Ability to strike local agreements with councils.

Disadvantages:

  • Limited overall budget and paid staff, relies heavily on volunteers to deliver programmes.

  • Governance can only reflect what its members inform it. Does membership reflect all riders adequately?

  • Traditionally focused on road/track and only recently broadening to focus on other disciplines.

  • No current remit for operating rider constructed trails. 

  • Has had difficulties in engagement with forestry management on both sides of the border in terms of access for recreation and racing.

  • Currently does not appear to represent small independent groups in engagement with land managers.

  • Lack of devolved government has slowed/ stopped progress until very recently.

Beicio Cymru (formerly Welsh Cycling)

Established: 2002

Advantages: 

  • Recent relaunch with greater grassroots focus including “Festiva” family friendly events.

  • Work with Sport Wales to help strategic investment into cycling infrastructure in all disciplines, including mountain biking.

  • Smaller size and devolved status may increase organisational flexibility. 

Disadvantages:

  • Had MTB Development Officers developing clubs and talent pathways as recently as 2019, but no longer has human resource available for this.

  • Historically not a large player in the mountain bike space, but becoming more involved via the Festiva (bike festival) programme.

  • Governance can only reflect what its members inform it. Does membership reflect all riders adequately?

British Cycling

Established: 1988

Advantages: 

  • Size and establishment.

  • “The Governing Body” seen as expert point of contact by land managers and third-party stakeholders.

  • Established entry level and elite rider programmes.

  • Provider of coaching and leader training, and insurance at all levels.

  • Works with Sport England to help strategic investment into cycling infrastructure in all disciplines, including mountain biking, via the Places to Ride scheme.

Disadvantages:

  • Size and history can create organisational inertia.

  • Perceived road and track bias by MTB community.

  • Governance can only reflect what its members inform it. Perceived lack of representation of the “typical rider”.

Scottish Cycling

Established: 1952

Advantages: 

  • History of supporting pioneering mountain bike initiatives including Scottish Mountain Bike Leaders Association and DMBinS.

  • Support for Scottish national race series' SXC and SDA.

  • Delivering Rock Up & Ride – an initiative to inspire children into cycling by providing fun MTB & BMX sessions and providing bikes to those who can’t afford them.

  • Supported many young athletes to go on to the British Cycling athlete development programmes. 

  • Work with Sport Scotland to help strategic investment into cycling infrastructure in all disciplines, including mountain biking.

Disadvantages:

  • Perceived as a road and track based organisation by some as it was founded by clubs from those disciplines.

  • Does not run its own individual membership product, rather counts British Cycling members that are based in Scotland as its membership base. This can lead to confusion of its role.

  • Clubs are the membership of Scottish Cycling and support to clubs is prioritised through its funding allocation from Sport Scotland.


Group 2

Recreational Governance

Cycling UK (formerly the Cyclists Touring Club CTC)

Established: 1878

Advantages: 

  • Long history of advocating successfully for cycle access to the countryside.

  • Creator of several long distance offroad journeys, the latest being the 2022 Traws Eryri in North Wales. 

  • Contributor to transport planning.

  • Provider of insurance.

  • Provider of basic cycle training.

Disadvantages:

  • More road and transport focused with no clear policy for mountain biking.

Developing Mountain Biking in Scotland (DMBinS)

Established: 2009

Advantages: 

  • Works to deliver a National Strategy.

  • Internationally respected.

  • Creates network of key stakeholders.

  • Negotiation and solution focussed.

  • Regional staff to deliver projects.

Disadvantages:

  • Model potentially restricted to certain size of country / area / population. 

  • Relies on annual grant funding for national and regional posts – this is time consuming and is fragile.

UK MTB Trail Alliance

Established: 2023

Advantages: 

  • Generates excitement in the MTB community about “something new”.

  • Grassroots base in touch with engaged enthusiast mountain bikers “on the ground”

  • Online platform and monthly Zoom meetings for networking and knowledge sharing.

  • Forming an umbrella organisation to bring together trail associations, informal trail groups and bike parks across the UK.

Disadvantages:

  • Voluntary structure risks resilience and capacity. 

  • Yet to develop formal membership structure to act on behalf of others, but currently in the process of registering as a charity.

  • Not recognised as “expert” by some land management stakeholders, who expressed preference for dealing with NGBs.

Walk Wheel Cyclet Tust (formerly Sustrans)

Established: 1977

Advantages: 

  • Strong record in cycling advocacy and policy influence. 

  • Provider of toolbox of cycling resources for design and planning professionals. 

  • Facilitator of the National Cycle Network.

  • Recognise the need for better connection of people to green and public space.

Disadvantages:

  • Primarily road and transport focused.

  • Do not focus on the progression from cycling for travel, to cycling for sporting pleasure.


Group 3

Other Governance

Bicycle Association

Established: 1973 (Traceable to 1890)

Advantages: 

  • Consumer focussed. 

  • Large reach into the cycle industry. 

  • Provider of training pathways for the industry 

  • Could leverage funding from industry. 

Disadvantages:

  • Focussed on supporting retail, not use of bicycles. 

  • Not mountain bike specific. 

  • No funding distribution pathways to support trails projects. 

IMBA Europe

Established: 2012

Advantages: 

  • International cooperation on advocacy and trail development.

  • Provision of training for volunteers.

  • Wide range of resources available.

Disadvantages:

  • Centralised European focus needs “translating” to each UK home nation.

Mountain Bike Wales

Established: 2004

Advantages: 

  • Set up as a Community Interest Company (CIC) to draw down funding, with Directors and a Steering Group overseeing investment.

  • Has previously acted as the voice of the mountain bike sector in Wales.

  • Direct links to the Welsh Government.

  • Website promoting Wales trail centres, bike parks approved trails.

Disadvantages:

  • Irregular funding limits investment in trails

  • Has lacked leadership and governance in recent years, limiting its reach and relevance for the sector.

  • No clear strategy for developing MTB.

Outdoor Industries Association (OIA)

Trade body for manufacturers, retailers and others providing products and services for the outdoor leisure pursuits market. Established: 2009

Advantages: 

  • Understanding of physical and mental health benefits.

  • Discusses industry issues at governmental level.

  • Feed into National Strategies ie. Sports Strategy.

Disadvantages:

  • Not clear how MTB would fit within in the structure at present (Who would join to represent MTB?).

Group 1

Sporting Governance

Cycling Ireland (& Cycling Ulster)

Established: Current form 2007. Historic line traceable to 1878.

Advantages: 

  • Club model facilitates racing and kids’ clubs.

  • Has achieved Stewardship trail management agreement via club at Rostrevor trail centre.

  • Small government so easier access to politicians.

  • Ability to strike local agreements with councils.

Disadvantages:

  • Limited overall budget and paid staff, relies heavily on volunteers to deliver programmes.

  • Governance can only reflect what its members inform it. Does membership reflect all riders adequately?

  • Traditionally focused on road/track and only recently broadening to focus on other disciplines.

  • No current remit for operating rider constructed trails. 

  • Has had difficulties in engagement with forestry management on both sides of the border in terms of access for recreation and racing.

  • Currently does not appear to represent small independent groups in engagement with land managers.

  • Lack of devolved government has slowed/ stopped progress until very recently.

Beicio Cymru (formerly Welsh Cycling)

Established: 2002

Advantages: 

  • Recent relaunch with greater grassroots focus including “Festiva” family friendly events.

  • Work with Sport Wales to help strategic investment into cycling infrastructure in all disciplines, including mountain biking.

  • Smaller size and devolved status may increase organisational flexibility. 

Disadvantages:

  • Had MTB Development Officers developing clubs and talent pathways as recently as 2019, but no longer has human resource available for this.

  • Historically not a large player in the mountain bike space, but becoming more involved via the Festiva (bike festival) programme.

  • Governance can only reflect what its members inform it. Does membership reflect all riders adequately?

British Cycling

Established: 1988

Advantages: 

  • Size and establishment.

  • “The Governing Body” seen as expert point of contact by land managers and third-party stakeholders.

  • Established entry level and elite rider programmes.

  • Provider of coaching and leader training, and insurance at all levels.

  • Works with Sport England to help strategic investment into cycling infrastructure in all disciplines, including mountain biking, via the Places to Ride scheme.

Disadvantages:

  • Size and history can create organisational inertia.

  • Perceived road and track bias by MTB community.

  • Governance can only reflect what its members inform it. Perceived lack of representation of the “typical rider”.

Scottish Cycling

Established: 1952

Advantages: 

  • History of supporting pioneering mountain bike initiatives including Scottish Mountain Bike Leaders Association and DMBinS.

  • Support for Scottish national race series' SXC and SDA.

  • Delivering Rock Up & Ride – an initiative to inspire children into cycling by providing fun MTB & BMX sessions and providing bikes to those who can’t afford them.

  • Supported many young athletes to go on to the British Cycling athlete development programmes. 

  • Work with Sport Scotland to help strategic investment into cycling infrastructure in all disciplines, including mountain biking.

Disadvantages:

  • Perceived as a road and track based organisation by some as it was founded by clubs from those disciplines.

  • Does not run its own individual membership product, rather counts British Cycling members that are based in Scotland as its membership base. This can lead to confusion of its role.

  • Clubs are the membership of Scottish Cycling and support to clubs is prioritised through its funding allocation from Sport Scotland.


Group 2

Recreational Governance

Cycling UK (formerly the Cyclists Touring Club CTC)

Established: 1878

Advantages: 

  • Long history of advocating successfully for cycle access to the countryside.

  • Creator of several long distance offroad journeys, the latest being the 2022 Traws Eryri in North Wales. 

  • Contributor to transport planning.

  • Provider of insurance.

  • Provider of basic cycle training.

Disadvantages:

  • More road and transport focused with no clear policy for mountain biking.

Developing Mountain Biking in Scotland (DMBinS)

Established: 2009

Advantages: 

  • Works to deliver a National Strategy.

  • Internationally respected.

  • Creates network of key stakeholders.

  • Negotiation and solution focussed.

  • Regional staff to deliver projects.

Disadvantages:

  • Model potentially restricted to certain size of country / area / population. 

  • Relies on annual grant funding for national and regional posts – this is time consuming and is fragile.

UK MTB Trail Alliance

Established: 2023

Advantages: 

  • Generates excitement in the MTB community about “something new”.

  • Grassroots base in touch with engaged enthusiast mountain bikers “on the ground”

  • Online platform and monthly Zoom meetings for networking and knowledge sharing.

  • Forming an umbrella organisation to bring together trail associations, informal trail groups and bike parks across the UK.

Disadvantages:

  • Voluntary structure risks resilience and capacity. 

  • Yet to develop formal membership structure to act on behalf of others, but currently in the process of registering as a charity.

  • Not recognised as “expert” by some land management stakeholders, who expressed preference for dealing with NGBs.

Walk Wheel Cyclet Tust (formerly Sustrans)

Established: 1977

Advantages: 

  • Strong record in cycling advocacy and policy influence. 

  • Provider of toolbox of cycling resources for design and planning professionals. 

  • Facilitator of the National Cycle Network.

  • Recognise the need for better connection of people to green and public space.

Disadvantages:

  • Primarily road and transport focused.

  • Do not focus on the progression from cycling for travel, to cycling for sporting pleasure.


Group 3

Other Governance

Bicycle Association

Established: 1973 (Traceable to 1890)

Advantages: 

  • Consumer focussed. 

  • Large reach into the cycle industry. 

  • Provider of training pathways for the industry 

  • Could leverage funding from industry. 

Disadvantages:

  • Focussed on supporting retail, not use of bicycles. 

  • Not mountain bike specific. 

  • No funding distribution pathways to support trails projects. 

IMBA Europe

Established: 2012

Advantages: 

  • International cooperation on advocacy and trail development.

  • Provision of training for volunteers.

  • Wide range of resources available.

Disadvantages:

  • Centralised European focus needs “translating” to each UK home nation.

Mountain Bike Wales

Established: 2004

Advantages: 

  • Set up as a Community Interest Company (CIC) to draw down funding, with Directors and a Steering Group overseeing investment.

  • Has previously acted as the voice of the mountain bike sector in Wales.

  • Direct links to the Welsh Government.

  • Website promoting Wales trail centres, bike parks approved trails.

Disadvantages:

  • Irregular funding limits investment in trails

  • Has lacked leadership and governance in recent years, limiting its reach and relevance for the sector.

  • No clear strategy for developing MTB.

Outdoor Industries Association (OIA)

Trade body for manufacturers, retailers and others providing products and services for the outdoor leisure pursuits market. Established: 2009

Advantages: 

  • Understanding of physical and mental health benefits.

  • Discusses industry issues at governmental level.

  • Feed into National Strategies ie. Sports Strategy.

Disadvantages:

  • Not clear how MTB would fit within in the structure at present (Who would join to represent MTB?).

Sponsors and Steering Group

Project Lead

Developing Mountain Biking in Scotland
Developing Mountain Biking in Scotland

Sponsor

SRAM
SRAM

Steering Group

  • Beicio Cymru
  • British Cycling
  • Cycling Ireland
  • Scottish Cycling
  • Forestry and Land Scotland
  • Forestry England
  • Natural Resources Wales
  • Outscape