2.8

Right, Wrong, or Making the Best of It?

2.8

Right, Wrong, or Making the Best of It?

2.8

Right, Wrong, or Making the Best of It?

A community organisation must be able to evolve with the trails and people it supports. Image Credit: Bike Corris Ltd.

All land managers stated any project within their organisations must be compatible with the three pillars of sustainability: Economic, Environmental and Social.

In terms of economic sustainability, riders across the UK gave many examples of previously popular trails suffering from neglect, highlighting the need for properly funded maintenance plans to be part of the planning and design criteria. This was echoed by bike park operators and professional trail constructors who stated maintenance was critical to rider experience and safety.

For Environment and Social sustainability, land managers expressed an initial preference towards having a single set of criteria to determine if a trail is “right” for its environment. Further discussion revealed that one list would not capture the complexities of the situation, and the steering group moved in favour of a trail needing three factors to be in harmony for it to meet Environmental and Social criteria:

  • Place: The trail must be sited in a suitable landscape to provide good ride quality, without causing undue negative impact on conservation, other users and site operations.

  • Time: The trail must be used at an appropriate time in the landscape’s lifecycle. For example, a trail may be closed during timber harvesting operations. Some trails are more suitable to permanence, whereas others may have a limited lifespan to coincide with other land uses. 

  • People: Any project must have the collaboration of the right representatives from each affected group, with riders as users of the trails being a key consideration. If the trail is not right for the users, then no matter how good its construction, riders will simply go elsewhere.

MTB experts and land managers agreed that the concept of “right” is fluid and constantly changing: For example, the discovery of a protected species. It may not be possible to achieve the perfectly “right” solution in every case and the best-compromise may be required. Phase 2 will include case studies to examine not just what has worked, but where compromise was needed to make each management method successful. 

All land managers stated any project within their organisations must be compatible with the three pillars of sustainability: Economic, Environmental and Social.

In terms of economic sustainability, riders across the UK gave many examples of previously popular trails suffering from neglect, highlighting the need for properly funded maintenance plans to be part of the planning and design criteria. This was echoed by bike park operators and professional trail constructors who stated maintenance was critical to rider experience and safety.

For Environment and Social sustainability, land managers expressed an initial preference towards having a single set of criteria to determine if a trail is “right” for its environment. Further discussion revealed that one list would not capture the complexities of the situation, and the steering group moved in favour of a trail needing three factors to be in harmony for it to meet Environmental and Social criteria:

  • Place: The trail must be sited in a suitable landscape to provide good ride quality, without causing undue negative impact on conservation, other users and site operations.

  • Time: The trail must be used at an appropriate time in the landscape’s lifecycle. For example, a trail may be closed during timber harvesting operations. Some trails are more suitable to permanence, whereas others may have a limited lifespan to coincide with other land uses. 

  • People: Any project must have the collaboration of the right representatives from each affected group, with riders as users of the trails being a key consideration. If the trail is not right for the users, then no matter how good its construction, riders will simply go elsewhere.

MTB experts and land managers agreed that the concept of “right” is fluid and constantly changing: For example, the discovery of a protected species. It may not be possible to achieve the perfectly “right” solution in every case and the best-compromise may be required. Phase 2 will include case studies to examine not just what has worked, but where compromise was needed to make each management method successful. 

All land managers stated any project within their organisations must be compatible with the three pillars of sustainability: Economic, Environmental and Social.

In terms of economic sustainability, riders across the UK gave many examples of previously popular trails suffering from neglect, highlighting the need for properly funded maintenance plans to be part of the planning and design criteria. This was echoed by bike park operators and professional trail constructors who stated maintenance was critical to rider experience and safety.

For Environment and Social sustainability, land managers expressed an initial preference towards having a single set of criteria to determine if a trail is “right” for its environment. Further discussion revealed that one list would not capture the complexities of the situation, and the steering group moved in favour of a trail needing three factors to be in harmony for it to meet Environmental and Social criteria:

  • Place: The trail must be sited in a suitable landscape to provide good ride quality, without causing undue negative impact on conservation, other users and site operations.

  • Time: The trail must be used at an appropriate time in the landscape’s lifecycle. For example, a trail may be closed during timber harvesting operations. Some trails are more suitable to permanence, whereas others may have a limited lifespan to coincide with other land uses. 

  • People: Any project must have the collaboration of the right representatives from each affected group, with riders as users of the trails being a key consideration. If the trail is not right for the users, then no matter how good its construction, riders will simply go elsewhere.

MTB experts and land managers agreed that the concept of “right” is fluid and constantly changing: For example, the discovery of a protected species. It may not be possible to achieve the perfectly “right” solution in every case and the best-compromise may be required. Phase 2 will include case studies to examine not just what has worked, but where compromise was needed to make each management method successful. 

Sponsors and Steering Group

Project Lead

Developing Mountain Biking in Scotland
Developing Mountain Biking in Scotland

Sponsor

SRAM
SRAM

Steering Group

  • Beicio Cymru
  • British Cycling
  • Cycling Ireland
  • Scottish Cycling
  • Forestry and Land Scotland
  • Forestry England
  • Natural Resources Wales
  • Outscape