1.1.3
The Need for a Variety of Trail Grades
1.1.3
The Need for a Variety of Trail Grades
1.1.3
The Need for a Variety of Trail Grades
The grading of official mountain bike trails broadly follows systems established in the ski industry, with a range of colours and symbols used to indicate the difficulty of the trail.
The systems used vary between continents, with the UK previously following the European model of Green = Easy; Blue = Moderate; Red = Difficult; Black = Severe. Each grade has several criteria such as track width, gradient and size of features such as drops and jumps.
Some bike parks use slightly different systems with multiple “Black Diamonds” to indicate trails of additional severity. At the time of writing, national forest bodies were an updated rating systems to include additional categories for trails more difficult that the previous offerings, and those not constructed to existing standards.
One of the best things about mountain biking is that the wide range of technical trail grades allow riders to enjoy the sport for the whole of their lives. Several different phases may be encountered in this journey:
Younger childhood needs a safe environment where children can experience gentle yet fun progression within their family group.
In teenage years, progression is at its most rapid, with a sudden increase in strength and ability. The opportunity to gain mastery of a skill and learn independence, for this age group is highly valuable.
Entering adulthood, riders consolidate their skillset and may seek greater technical challenges (such as racing), or a wider variety of experience at their given technical level. Many riders in this phase of life are keen to get involved in trail stewardship and to support trail building and development.
At some point in middle-age, riders may experience a step-change in the amount of time they dedicate to the sport or the risks they are willing to take. At this point the rider still values the physical and mental benefits of mountain biking, but increased time constraints and desire to reduce risk exposure is shown by the demand for less technical trails.
Later in life, a rider may either increase their time and dedication to previous levels, or return to the sport at a lower level of participation following injury or medical condition. The emergence of ebikes has enabled riders to return to the sport after absence and continue mountain biking following lifechanging injuries or medical conditions which would have been previously impossible. They also can extend a rider’s upper age well into retirement – the oldest rider encountered by this project was still enjoying trail centre riding at an inspiring 95 years old.
The 2015 Outdoor Industries Association report Getting Active Outdoors contains a wealth of research on reasons people engage in outdoor sports, many of which apply to mountain biking. Most interesting for this report is the concept of all outdoor sports having a “Lifecycle of Participation”. The Lifecycle of Participation graph shows the author’s interpretation on how this may be applied to mountain biking in terms of preferred trail technicality, but it is equally valid to consider frequency of riding or distance covered as the factor to measure participation
To support life-long riding, a trail network needs two key factors:
Progression
Progression is provided by having a range of trails of increasing grade. This is critical to allow new riders to improve their skills and confidence, so not to feel they are remaining a beginner in the sport. Well designed trails can include “opt-in” features of a higher grade to assist riders’ progression, without forcing them to commit to a whole trail of a higher grade.
Variety
Variety, both across the grades and within a given grade is desirable to allow riders to create a route of their choice at a given location. This flexibility is highly valued by riders as it allows uses to choose their trails to match their fitness, mood and desires on the day.
The website Trail Forks is an online trail management tool built around a crowd-sourced and user-moderated database to create a global resource of over 700,000 trails. This large single source of data allows us to make provisional comparisons on trail provision between countries, however due to its use-generated content this data must be taken as indicative and not absolute: E.g. A user’s perception of what constitutes a particular trail grade may be governed by their location and experience: A black trail in a lowland forest will not be the same as one found in Alpine mountains.
The grading of official mountain bike trails broadly follows systems established in the ski industry, with a range of colours and symbols used to indicate the difficulty of the trail.
The systems used vary between continents, with the UK previously following the European model of Green = Easy; Blue = Moderate; Red = Difficult; Black = Severe. Each grade has several criteria such as track width, gradient and size of features such as drops and jumps.
Some bike parks use slightly different systems with multiple “Black Diamonds” to indicate trails of additional severity. At the time of writing, national forest bodies were an updated rating systems to include additional categories for trails more difficult that the previous offerings, and those not constructed to existing standards.
One of the best things about mountain biking is that the wide range of technical trail grades allow riders to enjoy the sport for the whole of their lives. Several different phases may be encountered in this journey:
Younger childhood needs a safe environment where children can experience gentle yet fun progression within their family group.
In teenage years, progression is at its most rapid, with a sudden increase in strength and ability. The opportunity to gain mastery of a skill and learn independence, for this age group is highly valuable.
Entering adulthood, riders consolidate their skillset and may seek greater technical challenges (such as racing), or a wider variety of experience at their given technical level. Many riders in this phase of life are keen to get involved in trail stewardship and to support trail building and development.
At some point in middle-age, riders may experience a step-change in the amount of time they dedicate to the sport or the risks they are willing to take. At this point the rider still values the physical and mental benefits of mountain biking, but increased time constraints and desire to reduce risk exposure is shown by the demand for less technical trails.
Later in life, a rider may either increase their time and dedication to previous levels, or return to the sport at a lower level of participation following injury or medical condition. The emergence of ebikes has enabled riders to return to the sport after absence and continue mountain biking following lifechanging injuries or medical conditions which would have been previously impossible. They also can extend a rider’s upper age well into retirement – the oldest rider encountered by this project was still enjoying trail centre riding at an inspiring 95 years old.
The 2015 Outdoor Industries Association report Getting Active Outdoors contains a wealth of research on reasons people engage in outdoor sports, many of which apply to mountain biking. Most interesting for this report is the concept of all outdoor sports having a “Lifecycle of Participation”. The Lifecycle of Participation graph shows the author’s interpretation on how this may be applied to mountain biking in terms of preferred trail technicality, but it is equally valid to consider frequency of riding or distance covered as the factor to measure participation
To support life-long riding, a trail network needs two key factors:
Progression
Progression is provided by having a range of trails of increasing grade. This is critical to allow new riders to improve their skills and confidence, so not to feel they are remaining a beginner in the sport. Well designed trails can include “opt-in” features of a higher grade to assist riders’ progression, without forcing them to commit to a whole trail of a higher grade.
Variety
Variety, both across the grades and within a given grade is desirable to allow riders to create a route of their choice at a given location. This flexibility is highly valued by riders as it allows uses to choose their trails to match their fitness, mood and desires on the day.
The website Trail Forks is an online trail management tool built around a crowd-sourced and user-moderated database to create a global resource of over 700,000 trails. This large single source of data allows us to make provisional comparisons on trail provision between countries, however due to its use-generated content this data must be taken as indicative and not absolute: E.g. A user’s perception of what constitutes a particular trail grade may be governed by their location and experience: A black trail in a lowland forest will not be the same as one found in Alpine mountains.
The grading of official mountain bike trails broadly follows systems established in the ski industry, with a range of colours and symbols used to indicate the difficulty of the trail.
The systems used vary between continents, with the UK previously following the European model of Green = Easy; Blue = Moderate; Red = Difficult; Black = Severe. Each grade has several criteria such as track width, gradient and size of features such as drops and jumps.
Some bike parks use slightly different systems with multiple “Black Diamonds” to indicate trails of additional severity. At the time of writing, national forest bodies were an updated rating systems to include additional categories for trails more difficult that the previous offerings, and those not constructed to existing standards.
One of the best things about mountain biking is that the wide range of technical trail grades allow riders to enjoy the sport for the whole of their lives. Several different phases may be encountered in this journey:
Younger childhood needs a safe environment where children can experience gentle yet fun progression within their family group.
In teenage years, progression is at its most rapid, with a sudden increase in strength and ability. The opportunity to gain mastery of a skill and learn independence, for this age group is highly valuable.
Entering adulthood, riders consolidate their skillset and may seek greater technical challenges (such as racing), or a wider variety of experience at their given technical level. Many riders in this phase of life are keen to get involved in trail stewardship and to support trail building and development.
At some point in middle-age, riders may experience a step-change in the amount of time they dedicate to the sport or the risks they are willing to take. At this point the rider still values the physical and mental benefits of mountain biking, but increased time constraints and desire to reduce risk exposure is shown by the demand for less technical trails.
Later in life, a rider may either increase their time and dedication to previous levels, or return to the sport at a lower level of participation following injury or medical condition. The emergence of ebikes has enabled riders to return to the sport after absence and continue mountain biking following lifechanging injuries or medical conditions which would have been previously impossible. They also can extend a rider’s upper age well into retirement – the oldest rider encountered by this project was still enjoying trail centre riding at an inspiring 95 years old.
The 2015 Outdoor Industries Association report Getting Active Outdoors contains a wealth of research on reasons people engage in outdoor sports, many of which apply to mountain biking. Most interesting for this report is the concept of all outdoor sports having a “Lifecycle of Participation”. The Lifecycle of Participation graph shows the author’s interpretation on how this may be applied to mountain biking in terms of preferred trail technicality, but it is equally valid to consider frequency of riding or distance covered as the factor to measure participation
To support life-long riding, a trail network needs two key factors:
Progression
Progression is provided by having a range of trails of increasing grade. This is critical to allow new riders to improve their skills and confidence, so not to feel they are remaining a beginner in the sport. Well designed trails can include “opt-in” features of a higher grade to assist riders’ progression, without forcing them to commit to a whole trail of a higher grade.
Variety
Variety, both across the grades and within a given grade is desirable to allow riders to create a route of their choice at a given location. This flexibility is highly valued by riders as it allows uses to choose their trails to match their fitness, mood and desires on the day.
The website Trail Forks is an online trail management tool built around a crowd-sourced and user-moderated database to create a global resource of over 700,000 trails. This large single source of data allows us to make provisional comparisons on trail provision between countries, however due to its use-generated content this data must be taken as indicative and not absolute: E.g. A user’s perception of what constitutes a particular trail grade may be governed by their location and experience: A black trail in a lowland forest will not be the same as one found in Alpine mountains.
1.1.3.A
The MTB Lifecycle of Participation
1.1.3.B
Distribution of Trail Grade by Country
This plot shows a useful estimate of the composition of trail networks around Europe.
The different distribution of trail grades in the UK is interesting but not fully understood.
The initial investment required and the need for a higher maintenance budget for blue and red graded trails may have restricted the number of these trails. As identified through several expert interviews and riders’ surveys they are essential as an entry point and then for progression.
Many riders enjoy these grades of trails and may never wish to explore more difficult terrain. However, with modern bike technology and the sheer enjoyment of riding modern trails, riders wishing to progress onto Black and Double Black trails, including natural surfaced trails, can so do relatively quickly. We believe the UK’s relatively good provision of harder graded trails demonstrates the demand for more technical riding.
Riders surveyed stated the lack of official provision of more technical trails has led to them building their own trails. Whilst this brings land management challenges, it does indicate that riders using this level of trail value the opportunity to give input into how trails are designed and built to progress their riding and the sport.
Sponsors and Steering Group