4.4

What Support Is Required

4.4

What Support Is Required

4.4

What Support Is Required

Applying management plans retrospectively is challenging, but possible.

Looking at responses to surveys by land managers and trail association, the table shows both groups stating they needed extra support in common areas. The themes of communication and understanding, and building relationships were raised as essential foundations for any project to be successful. The need for additional knowledge and standardised process was also repeated, both in surveys and individual interviews.

Although the “trail association” model has been widely successful, as interviews progressed, we soon found a wider range of management approaches could provide greater flexibility for all involved. The model appropriate for a large world-class destination, for example, would be excessive for a small woodland used only by local riders.

The use of existing management systems was preferred by land managers, who need cost (and time) effective solutions which they trust to provide adequate legal protection. However, those running trail associations pointed out that a manageable workload is critical to encourage buy-in from volunteers, and to maintain support for taking a formal approach to trail management. 

Riders recognised the value in forming legitimate organisations and strongly requested guidance on how to go about this, and what form the organisation should take. Land managers reflected this need, stating they would expect the NGB of a sport to take a lead role in this organisation. Underpinning the application of all management methods is the need to improve communication and understanding between all parties. This foundation work will have its own work package as we will see in chapter 5.

Deciding how to provide help to the wide range of management models available appeared daunting at first, but when feedback from land managers and trail associations was broken down common themes emerged. The Trail Management Support Table shows examples of what work is required at each level. This framework will drive the work packages in the second phase of this project, outlined in Chapter 5.

Applying management plans retrospectively is challenging, but possible.

Looking at responses to surveys by land managers and trail association, the table shows both groups stating they needed extra support in common areas. The themes of communication and understanding, and building relationships were raised as essential foundations for any project to be successful. The need for additional knowledge and standardised process was also repeated, both in surveys and individual interviews.

Although the “trail association” model has been widely successful, as interviews progressed, we soon found a wider range of management approaches could provide greater flexibility for all involved. The model appropriate for a large world-class destination, for example, would be excessive for a small woodland used only by local riders.

The use of existing management systems was preferred by land managers, who need cost (and time) effective solutions which they trust to provide adequate legal protection. However, those running trail associations pointed out that a manageable workload is critical to encourage buy-in from volunteers, and to maintain support for taking a formal approach to trail management. 

Riders recognised the value in forming legitimate organisations and strongly requested guidance on how to go about this, and what form the organisation should take. Land managers reflected this need, stating they would expect the NGB of a sport to take a lead role in this organisation. Underpinning the application of all management methods is the need to improve communication and understanding between all parties. This foundation work will have its own work package as we will see in chapter 5.

Deciding how to provide help to the wide range of management models available appeared daunting at first, but when feedback from land managers and trail associations was broken down common themes emerged. The Trail Management Support Table shows examples of what work is required at each level. This framework will drive the work packages in the second phase of this project, outlined in Chapter 5.

Applying management plans retrospectively is challenging, but possible.

Looking at responses to surveys by land managers and trail association, the table shows both groups stating they needed extra support in common areas. The themes of communication and understanding, and building relationships were raised as essential foundations for any project to be successful. The need for additional knowledge and standardised process was also repeated, both in surveys and individual interviews.

Although the “trail association” model has been widely successful, as interviews progressed, we soon found a wider range of management approaches could provide greater flexibility for all involved. The model appropriate for a large world-class destination, for example, would be excessive for a small woodland used only by local riders.

The use of existing management systems was preferred by land managers, who need cost (and time) effective solutions which they trust to provide adequate legal protection. However, those running trail associations pointed out that a manageable workload is critical to encourage buy-in from volunteers, and to maintain support for taking a formal approach to trail management. 

Riders recognised the value in forming legitimate organisations and strongly requested guidance on how to go about this, and what form the organisation should take. Land managers reflected this need, stating they would expect the NGB of a sport to take a lead role in this organisation. Underpinning the application of all management methods is the need to improve communication and understanding between all parties. This foundation work will have its own work package as we will see in chapter 5.

Deciding how to provide help to the wide range of management models available appeared daunting at first, but when feedback from land managers and trail associations was broken down common themes emerged. The Trail Management Support Table shows examples of what work is required at each level. This framework will drive the work packages in the second phase of this project, outlined in Chapter 5.

4.4.A

The Top 5 Areas Needing Additional Support

Land Managers

Trail Associations

1

Guidance on conveying your concerns regarding trail locations in relation to core activities and conservation constraint to the MTB community

Education to help improve relationships between riders and other trail users.

2

Education to help improve relations between riders and other trail users

Assistance and clarification regarding process to officialise the trails

3

Training on trail management, volunteer management, insurance, risk assessments etc.

Mentoring on designing, securing permissions and funding and construction of new trails

4

Signposting to sources of additional information to increase knowledge (ie meeting the needs of the local MTB population)

Signposting to sources of funding to facilitate an organisation

5

Guidance and templates to simplify the processes of documentation, insurance, risk assessments etc.

Education to improve behaviour and image of riders using the location

4.4.B

Support Required at All Trail Management Levels

While support is required at all trail management levels, it is important to remember the the level chosen must be appropriate to the site. An organisation with multiple sites could have many management levels, where appropriate.


Management Method

Support

Benefit 

All Levels

Influence key decision makers on top level benefits of MTBing.

Increase support for mountain bike provision and support at national and local governance levels, and with potential funders outside of the sport.

All Levels

Inform decision makers’ perception of the sport.

Increase acceptance of the sport by moving attention away from the minority “extreme” and into the benefits provided by the middle ground.

All Levels

Facilitate reliable points of contact for MTB community.

Reliable communications builds trust between land managers and the MTB community, allowing discussion to move the whole management process forward.

Site Ownership

Experienced staff to provide guidance and lessons from past work.

Enabling businesses to invest in the sport and help develop thriving MTB economies.

Lease of Site

Experienced staff to facilitate negotiations and provide guidance on what land managers require.

Ease lease agreement process and help understand contracts.

Adoption by Volunteers

Agree and standardise adoption process, , set up and constitution of the group / organisation and legal requirements.

Reduced replication of effort. Increase confidence from land managers. Standardise template for insurers to quote for cover against. 

Stewardship by Volunteers

Agree and standardise Stewardship agreement or Memorandum of Understanding.

Create an understanding of boundaries and thresholds in which this template can operate.

Partnership with other organisations at site

Work with other NGBs / Land Managers to determine how mountain bike provision fits positively within a shared space. Provide templates for use in such spaces.

Raises the professional image of mountain biking. Reduces replication of effort. Brings MTB to the table as “equal” among site users.

Permission

Create communication pathways to bring mountain biking into discussions on countryside management.

Raises the public image of mountain biking. Opens dialogue to gain local trail network improvements such as completing bridleway routes without trespass (outside Scotland). Deliverable in a shorter timescale than changing access legislation.

Tolerance

Create communication pathways to listen to land manager’s constraints and concerns. Create education programme to improve MTBers and MTB industry’s understanding of the countryside. Build trust between the land management and mountain bike communities at top level.

Improved tolerance of mountain bikers as countryside user groups. Reduced user conflict. Increased opportunities for moving up the trail management ladder and improving trail provision.

Do nothing

NA

NA

Bad Things

Raise awareness on areas such as wildlife crime or criminal damage of which riders may not be aware.

Reduce instances of environmental damage improves MTB’s image with landowners and other site users. 

Sponsors and Steering Group

Project Lead

Developing Mountain Biking in Scotland
Developing Mountain Biking in Scotland

Sponsor

SRAM
SRAM

Steering Group

  • Beicio Cymru
  • British Cycling
  • Cycling Ireland
  • Scottish Cycling
  • Forestry and Land Scotland
  • Forestry England
  • Natural Resources Wales
  • Outscape